Common Ground homeCitizens For Public Power
 
 
 
     

Boy scout gone bad
 

Science Matters by David Suzuki

  auteur
Everyone knows that Canada is a wild land and that Canadians are all environmentalists at heart. We love nature and go to great lengths to protect it. We are the boy scouts of the international community.

If that image was ever true, it certainly isn't anymore. Environmental groups have for years been decrying Canada's poor performance on environmental issues. Now, even economic think-tanks are saying the same thing.

Recently, the Conference Board of Canada, a respected institution focusing on economics, released its Performance and Potential report on the state of Canadian society. While the board largely praised Canada's economic status, it took our nation to task on our environmental record, heading its environment section saying Canada needs to clean up its act.

The board compared Canada's performance with that of the other 23 members of the Organization for Economic Co - operation and Development (OECD - the leading nations of the developed world) in six categories, including the environment, economy, society, education, health and innovation. In five of the six, Canada at least made it into the top 12. But in environment, Canada places a sad 16th.

The fact is, when it comes to protecting nature, Canada lags behind. And this is having other ramifications. Protecting nature is not about just saving species or trees. It's a matter of maintaining the natural systems that provide us with things like clean air and water - things that our economy and quality of life ultimately depend on too. So, as our commitment to the environment wanes, our social index ranking drops. For years Canada topped the United Nations' Human Development Index, but we've slipped - first to third place, and now a lowly eighth.

When compared to other OECD countries, Canada ranks poorly in terms of water quality, waste generation and disposal, and air quality. Canada actually places second to worst in terms of nitrogen oxide emissions (which cause smog) and worst in terms of carbon dioxide emissions (which cause climate change). Energy wastefulness is partly to blame, according to the report, as it was in the case of the blackout in Ontario this summer.

Denmark, Sweden and Austria are just a few examples of countries that are doing a much better job of managing their natural capital through environmental planning, the use of best available technologies and the enforcement of strict environmental standards. The report points out that these countries also do well economically, dispelling the notion that protecting environmental health must somehow be an economic burden. In fact, the opposite is true.

Yet, strangely the board slips back into old-fashioned thinking when describing the Kyoto treaty on climate change. It lists the treaty as an important international agreement, but discusses it largely as a cost to the economy that will have to be met, rather than an opportunity to bring down other costs, like air pollution and energy waste.

The report also mentions the rising costs of health care due to an aging population, but doesn't consider the costs of a changing climate on our health care system. This summer, 35,000 people, mostly the elderly, died in Europe from heat waves. The World Meteorological Organization estimates that heat-related deaths could double worldwide in the next 20 years. Unless we tackle climate change, we will face un increasingly unstable, unhealthy and expensive future.

Still, the Conference Board of Canada is onto something. It recognizes the necessity of maintaining a healthy environment in order to maintain a healthy economy and quality of life. Not a new idea, to be sure, but one many of our leaders seem to have forgotten. Right now, Canada simply isn't measuring up. We really aren't boy scouts anymore.

Take the Nature Challenge and learn more at www.davidsuzuki.org.






Top
 
SUBSCRIBE HERE



Subscribe to Common Ground

Don't miss an issue - get Common Ground delivered to you wherever you are!
Subscribe here